Is a half-day CMS build worth it for a small club website?
In this example, yes. For AG Badminton Brisbane, half a day of bespoke CMS plumbing beat five days of previous setup plus about $47 a month in CMS fees and admin hosting. With those figures, the replacement breaks even in about eight months. Those are example numbers, not a promise for every site.
My latest work on that site was a small CMS built into the existing website. The previous solution needed separate hosting for its admin portal, carried a $15 monthly fee, and had taken the previous contractor five days to set up.
The bespoke version took me about half a day to get the plumbing done. It reuses the website and existing database and authentication infrastructure, so there’s no separate admin portal deployment to host.
That half-day figure covers the plumbing. It isn’t a claim that every editor, refinement, test, and deployment step took four hours in total. But it made a small, purpose-built CMS a practical option for this site.
What does the business actually need to edit?
The club needs to keep events, coaches, and Pro Team players up to date. Those are specific jobs, so I built editors for those records inside the Next.js website.
Site admins can create and edit events, upload photos, manage the coach and player lists, and change their order. They can also restore removed entries if they make a mistake.
The latest changes add live previews and photo guidance. An admin can see the public card before saving and check how the photo will crop. That matters when the same event photo appears in different shapes across the site.
The CMS uses Neon for the database and authentication, and Vercel Blob for uploaded photos. Saving content refreshes the relevant public pages without a code change or redeploy. General page layouts and other copy still live in code.
Keeping the scope this small avoids paying for a general publishing system when the business needs a handful of structured editors.
Why build around the business instead of buying a CMS?
There was another benefit that doesn’t have a neat dollar figure. What I built matched what the club needed. The event editor handles events, and the roster editors handle coaches and players. Their fields and previews follow the content already on the website.
Bringing in an external CMS means fitting those requirements into its content model, then adapting the codebase to its APIs and publishing workflow. For a site this small, that can mean spending time making the website fit the CMS when the editing requirements were straightforward to begin with.
Every external dependency is a long-term commitment. Once the website relies on it, someone has to maintain the integration, handle changes, and keep the content working through upgrades. Removing it later means another migration. That work continues after the initial setup and sits outside the monthly subscription price.
The bespoke CMS still has dependencies, and I still own its maintenance. The benefit here was reusing infrastructure already in place and building the editing workflow around the club’s needs. I haven’t assigned a dollar saving to that fit or to avoiding another CMS integration, so neither appears in the ROI calculation below.
Where do the savings come from?
The old setup had two recurring costs: the $15 monthly CMS fee and Vercel Pro for the admin portal, which cost A$32 per month. Treating the CMS fee as AUD too, that’s $47 per month, $564 per year, or $1,692 over three years.
The new setup removes the separate admin deployment and CMS subscription. It still uses hosting, a database, authentication, and photo storage. Reusing infrastructure reduces the extra services to pay for and maintain, but actual savings depend on whether the new workload adds charges to those services.
Build effort is another part of the comparison. At an example contract rate of $750 per day for both sides, the previous five-day setup would cost $3,750. Half a day would cost $375. That’s $3,375 less setup cost, a 90% reduction for the work being compared.
Those are example figures, not the previous contractor’s invoice or my actual rate. The scope also needs to match before treating the time comparison as a like-for-like saving.
When does the replacement break even?
If the business already paid for the old CMS, that setup cost is sunk. I wouldn’t count it as money recovered by replacing the system today. The replacement earns back its cost through future savings.
The calculation is:
Monthly saving = $15 + old monthly admin hosting
- additional monthly costs of the new CMS
Break-even months = total replacement cost / monthly saving
Total replacement cost should include all chargeable work needed to make the replacement usable, including migration and deployment. If monthly savings are zero or negative, there’s no break-even through recurring cost savings alone.
For a worked example, half a day at $750 per day gives a $375 replacement cost. This uses the plumbing time as the cost basis for illustration. The example treats the day rate and CMS fee as AUD, alongside the A$32 hosting bill. Assume no additional monthly infrastructure or maintenance cost.
| Old admin hosting per month | Net monthly saving | Annual saving | Break-even |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0, counting only the CMS fee | $15 | $180 | 25 months |
| $32, previous Vercel Pro hosting | $47 | $564 | 8 months |
Including the previous $32 monthly hosting cost, the example replacement pays for itself in about eight months. If the full replacement costs more than $375, the payback period increases. Any extra running or maintenance cost reduces the monthly saving too.
What does that mean for ROI?
Using the same $375 build and $47 monthly saving, three years of avoided costs total $1,692. After subtracting the build, the net saving is $1,317.
ROI = (avoided costs - replacement cost) / replacement cost × 100
= ($1,692 - $375) / $375 × 100
= 351.2% over three years
That example has an ROI of 50.4% after the first year, because $564 of avoided costs covers the $375 build and leaves $189 in net savings. It breaks even in about eight months and reaches 351.2% ROI by the end of year three. Counting only the $15 fee gives a three-year net saving of $165 and an ROI of 44% on the same assumed build cost.
These are scenarios, not measured returns. They leave out differences in ongoing maintenance and any value from staff making updates themselves. The actual contract rate, the currency of the CMS fee, complete replacement effort, and new running costs determine the real result.
Can I calculate my own savings?
Change the figures below to compare setup costs or work out whether replacing an existing CMS pays for itself. The example starts with $750 per day for both contractors, a $15 monthly CMS fee, and the previous $32 monthly admin hosting cost. It treats all amounts as AUD. Adjust the figures and include any maintenance costs for your own comparison.
Try your own numbers
The example uses $750 per day on both sides and the five days spent setting up the previous CMS. Previous hosting starts at A$32 per month for Vercel Pro. The example treats all amounts as AUD. Use the same currency throughout.
Comparing two new builds
This comparison includes setup costs on both sides.
- Previous setup cost
- $3,750
- Bespoke build cost
- $375
- Upfront saving
- $3,375
- Total saving over 36 months
- $5,067
Total costs over 36 months: $5,442 for the previous approach and $375 for bespoke.
Replacing an existing CMS
The old setup is already paid for. Only future savings repay the replacement.
- Net monthly saving
- $47
- Annual saving
- $564
- Replacement break-even
- 8 months
- Replacement ROI over 36 months
- 351.2%
Net saving after the replacement build over 36 months: $1,317.
Why did this suit AG Badminton?
For this website, a focused CMS gives the club control over the content that changes most often without a separate admin application to run. The editors fit the club’s workflow, and the codebase has one fewer external system to accommodate and maintain. Reusing the existing infrastructure kept the initial work manageable, and the latest previews make those editors easier to use.
The $15 fee looked small on its own. Once I included admin hosting and setup effort, building a few editors inside the website was worth considering. Half a day for the plumbing was enough to make that choice practical, and the break-even calculation gives the business a way to judge the saving over time.
FAQ
How much can you save each month?
In the worked example, avoiding a $15 CMS fee and A$32 admin hosting saves about $47 a month, or $564 a year, if the new setup adds no extra monthly cost.
When does the replacement break even?
At a $375 example build cost and $47 monthly saving, about eight months. If you only count the $15 fee, it stretches to about 25 months.
Is the 351% ROI a measured result?
No. It’s a scenario using example day rates and assumed monthly costs, not the previous contractor’s invoice or a measured return.
Why build editors instead of using an external CMS?
The club only needed to edit events, coaches, and Pro Team players. A few focused editors reused the existing website infrastructure and avoided another long-term CMS dependency.